ARCHIVED — Vol. 145, No. 41 — October 8, 2011

Regulations Amending the Alberta Fishery RegulatioStatutoryns, 1998

authority

Fisheries Act

Sponsoring department

Department of Fisheries and Oceans

REGULATORY IMPACT
ANALYSIS STATEMENT

(This statement is not part of the Regulations.)

Issue and objectives

The Alberta Fishery Regulations, 1998 (the Regulations), made pursuant to the Fisheries Act, apply to the proper management and control of fisheries and the conservation and protection of the fish in the province of Alberta.

The proposed amendments to the Regulations will address three issues:

• (a) Currently, the Regulations allow fish taken by means of angling to be possessed up to 100 m from the waters from which they were taken. The distance between the water body where live fish have been taken and where they can be possessed is too large. The reason this distance is too large is that even if anglers respect the 100 m maximum distance, a fish caught in one water body could be intentionally or unintentionally moved to another water body where the species is not present. This distance also makes enforcement and compliance activities more difficult to conduct and less effective, since most enforcement activities take place near the shore. This makes compliance monitoring more difficult, especially if fishers can move live fish a significant distance from the shore of the water body from where the fish was caught. This issue is in the context of the negative impacts and rising occurrence, either intentionally or unintentionally, of the illegal introduction of fish species into water bodies (from which the fish did not originate) in Alberta.
  
• (b) A number of fines in the Regulations are not current, and they do not act as appropriate deterrents to illegal fishing activities (e.g. overfishing). As well, the short form descriptions of the offences are not always clear in the Regulations, which makes it difficult for enforcement officers to interpret the provisions. Therefore, changes are required to both the definitions of the offences and the actual fine amounts.
  
• (c) The Standing Joint Committee for the Scrutiny of Regulations (SJC), under the authority of the Statutory Instruments Act, has reviewed the Regulations and found that there are discrepancies between the English and French wording of the Regulations. Specifically, the English wording is more consistent with the intent of the Regulations, and therefore changes to the French wording are required.
  

The amendments being proposed to the Regulations are intended to achieve three objectives:

• (a) Deter anglers from releasing fish into bodies of water other than the waters it was taken from, by restricting the distance live fish can be possessed;
  
• (b) Increase the fine amounts for offences where the current fines are not considered to be in line with other jurisdictions or where the fines may be insufficient to deter illegal fishing activity; and
  
• (c) Respond to the SJC concerns by adding clarity to the French version of the Regulations.
  

The amendments will ensure the Regulations accurately reflect the current management of the fishery.

Description and rationale

The proposed amendments will further restrict the possession of live fish taken by anglers, modify the fine amounts for several offences where the current fines are not considered appropriate, and amend one section of the Regulations to ensure the French and English versions properly reflect the Regulations’ intent.

The amendments being proposed for the Regulations would make changes to

Paragraph 5(b): Possession and use of live fish

The Regulations currently allow fish taken by means of angling to be possessed up to 100 m from the waters from which they were taken. However, paragraph 5(b) would be amended to narrow that distance to 5 m. The change was suggested by stakeholders and is intended to deter the illegal stocking of live fish (to waters other than the waters from which they were taken). Fish species have been unlawfully transferred into water bodies and into drainages where these species do not exist naturally; this activity affects the quality of existing fisheries and has ecological implications. Therefore, reducing the distance between the shores of the water body where the fish has been caught and where it can be possessed should reduce the risk of introducing the caught fish to a new water body, and should improve the effectiveness of compliance and enforcement activities. These amendments would still allow anglers to conduct their activities and would not impact current fishing or sporting tournaments and events, as Alberta has provincial laws (see footnote 1) that address these activities.

Schedule 9: Prescribed offences and fines

Schedule 9 of the Regulations is a table that outlines the prescribed offences and fines for anglers. The following proposed amendments would clarify wording surrounding offences to more accurately describe the offence of failing to return a prohibited fish to waters from which it was caught. Other amendments would adjust certain fines to be more restrictive.

The amendments being proposed for the Regulations would make changes to

• (a) increase the prescribed fine amounts for exceeding daily catch and possession limits. Currently, this fine is set at $100, plus $20 for each fish in excess of the quota to a maximum of $1,000. The new fines would be $200 for this offence, plus $50 for each fish in excess of the quota to a maximum of 10 fish. (see footnote 2)
  
• (b) increase the prescribed fine amount for angling using too many lines (in open water or in ice-covered water) from $50 for each offence to $100. (see footnote 3)
  
• (c) split the current fine, which is $200 for both barbed hooks versus other prohibited equipment, into two separate parts. The first fine would address the offence and fine for the use of a hook except a barbless hook, proposing a fine of $100. All other offences regarding prohibited equipment, which address the use of illegal sportfishing gear, would remain at $200. The offence of using a barbed hook is quite minor when compared to the use of other illegal sportfishing gear. The reduced fine better reflects the nature of the offence because this offence has limited impacts on a fishery.
  
• (d) amend the definition listed in Schedule 9 to clarify the definition of “Release of prohibited fish.” As it is currently written in the schedule, the description of the offence is too broad to be properly understood (even implying that no fish could ever be brought home).
  

By changing the fine amounts, anglers would more likely be deterred from contravening fishing regulations. Alberta’s waters are under significant pressure, and can be vulnerable to the impact of overfishing. These amendments would therefore help to improve the conservation of Alberta’s fishery resources.

Part 2: Authority to Fish — English-French concurrence

The Standing Joint Committee for the Scrutiny of Regulations has pointed out to Fisheries and Oceans Canada that the language used in the English version of the Regulations is more in line with the regulatory intent and much more extensive in its application. The amendments being proposed for Part 2: Authority to Fish would make changes to the French version of the Regulations to reflect the intent of the English version of the Regulations. This would ensure that the two versions of the Regulations are more harmonized.

Consultation

The proposal to further restrict the possession of live fish [paragraph 5(b)] was submitted by angling stakeholders, as these groups were concerned about the loss of stocked fisheries due to the introduction of invasive species, and the potential for those species to spread beyond their present distribution. The distance of 5 m was an arbitrary distance chosen by stakeholders.

The proposal to amend paragraph 5(b) was sent to members of the Alberta Fisheries Management Roundtable for review (and further distribution to their members) with invitations to attend local consultation meetings. There are approximately 80 members invited to attend the Roundtable, and most are representatives of fisheries stakeholder organizations including numerous societies, industries, aboriginal groups, and sport and commercial groups at the local and regional level. The recommendation to tighten the restrictions on the possession of live fish to 5 m was approved by the provincial minister of Sustainable Resource Development in early 2010. No significant concerns or comments were received by members of the Alberta Fisheries Management Roundtable that would suggest a negative reaction by stakeholders and/or the public.

Although the amendments to the fine adjustments are more restrictive, these changes are not expected to receive an adverse reaction from stakeholders.

Implementation, enforcement and service standards

The proposed amendment would not generate any new costs in terms of enforcement, as no additional enforcement resources would be required to implement the proposed amendment.

The proposed amendments would be communicated to the angling community and the public through press releases. The new distance of 5 m, which would restrict the possession and use of live fish, as well as the amended definition listed in schedule 9, would both be published in the Alberta Guide to Sportfishing Regulations in 2012, and would inform anglers of these changes.

All the proposed amendments to the prescribed offences and fines in schedule 9 would be published in the Specified Penalty Listing to inform anglers of the new fines and short descriptions of the offences. Anyone wishing to have a copy could contact the Alberta Queen’s Printer.

Contacts

Samia Hirani
Regulatory Analyst
Legislative and Regulatory Affairs
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
200 Kent Street
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A 0E6
Telephone: 613-990-0122
Email: samia.hirani@dfo-mpo.gc.ca

Pat Dunford
Head
Legislative and Advisory Services
Enforcement-Field Services Branch
Fish and Wildlife Division
Alberta Sustainable Resource Development
9920 108th Street
Edmonton, Alberta
T5K 2M4
Telephone: 780-427-4277
Email: Pat.Dunford@gov.ab.ca

PROPOSED REGULATORY TEXT

Notice is hereby given that the Governor in Council, pursuant to section 43 (see footnote a) and subsection 79.7(5) (see footnote b) of the Fisheries Act (see footnote c), proposes to make the annexed Regulations Amending the Alberta Fishery Regulations, 1998.

Interested persons may make representations concerning the proposed Regulations within 30 days after the date of publication of this notice. All such representations must cite the Canada Gazette, Part Ⅰ, and the date of publication of this notice, and be addressed to Samia Hirani, Regulatory Analyst, Legislative and Regulatory Affairs, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Ottawa, Ontario (tel.: 613-990-0122; email: samia.hirani@dfo-mpo.gc.ca) or Pat Dunford, Head, Legislative and Advisory Services, Enforcement-Field Services Branch, Fish and Wildlife Division, Edmonton, Alberta (tel.: 780-427-4277; email: Pat.Dunford@gov.ab.ca).

Ottawa, September 29, 2011

JURICA ČAPKUN
Assistant Clerk of the Privy Council

REGULATIONS AMENDING THE ALBERTA FISHERY REGULATIONS, 1998

AMENDMENTS

1. Paragraph 5(b) of the Alberta Fishe ry Regulations, 1998 (see footnote 4) is replaced by the following:

• (b) is engaged in angling, caught the fish in the waters in which the person is angling, and the fish are within 5 m of those waters.
  

2. (1) Paragraph 13.1(p) of the French version of the Regulations is replaced by the following:

• p) la séparation des poissons selon leur espèce avant et pendant leur transport;
  

(2) Paragraph 13.1(r) of the French version of the Regulations is replaced by the following:

• r) les espèces et les tailles de poissons qui doivent être libérés et la façon de les libérer;
  

3. Schedule 9 to the Regulations is replaced by the Schedule 9 set out in the schedule to these Regulations.

COMING INTO FORCE

4. These Regulations come into force on the day on which they are registered.

SCHEDULE
(Section 3)

SCHEDULE 9
(Sections 35 and 36)

PRESCRIBED OFFENCES AND FINES

Item	Column 1 Provision of Regulations	Column 2 Description of Offence	Column 3 Fine ($)
1.	4	Fishing in closed waters	200
2.	5-6	Possessing live fish without authorization	200
3.	7	Failing to release unauthorised fish immediately or in a manner that causes least harm	100
4.	8	Placing in water bait not attached to a hook	50
5.	9	Fishing with prohibited light	150
6.	13	Sportfishing without authorization	100
7.	13	Fishing, other than sportfishing, without authorization	250
8.	15	Sportfishing in closed waters	200
9.	16	Catching and retaining more than daily quota	200, plus 50 for each fish in excess of the quota to a maximum of 10 fish
10.	17	Exceeding possession limit	200, plus 50 for each fish in excess of possession limit to a maximum of 10 fish
11.	19(a)	Angling with more than three hooks on a line	50
12.	19(b)	Angling with a hook with more than three points on a common shaft	50
13.	19(c)	Angling with a lure with more than three hooks as part of it	50
14.	19(d)	Angling with more than one line in open water	100
15.	19(e)	Angling with more than two lines in ice-covered water	100
16.	19(f)	Angling with spring-loaded hook	100
17.	19(g)	Angling using prohibited fish as bait	200
18.	20(a)	Fishing by snagging	200
19.	20(b)	Possessing fish taken by snagging	200
20.	20(c)	Possessing a snagging device	200
21.	20(d)	Possessing a gaff hook while angling	200
22.	21	Being more than 30 m from any line in water	50
23.	22	Angling through ice in specified waters	200
24.	23	Sportfishing with prohibited gear	100 for the use of a hook, except a barbless hook. For all other offences of prohibited gear, 200
25.	23	Sportfishing with prohibited bait	200
26.	24	Fishing with dip net for fish other than bait fish	200
27.	24	Fishing with seine net for fish other than bait fish	200
28.	24	Fishing with minnow trap for fish other than bait fish	200
29.	24	Fishing with dip net in prohibited waters	150
30.	24	Fishing with seine net in prohibited waters	150
31.	24	Fishing with minnow trap in prohibited waters	150
32.	25	Fishing with improperly marked minnow trap	100
33.	25	Fishing with oversized minnow trap	150
34.	25	Fishing with more than two minnow traps	150
35.	26	Fishing with oversized seine net	150
36.	27	Fishing with bow and arrow for prohibited species	150
37.	27	Fishing with cross bow	150
38.	28	Fishing with spear using prohibited means of propulsion	150
39.	28	Fishing with spear while not swimming	150
40.	28	Fishing with spear for prohibited species	150

[41-1-o]

• Footnote 1
  Paragraph 5(a) of the Alberta Fishery Regulations, 1998 allows an exception to the proposed amendment to 5(b), which allows an angler to possess live fish if they are authorized to do so under the provincial act. In Alberta, the provincial Minister has the authority to set terms and conditions for a licence that would allow an angler to possess live fish for sporting tournaments and events under the following pieces of legislation and regulation: Fisheries (Alberta) Act, General Fisheries (Alberta) Regulation, and Fisheries (Ministerial) Regulation.
• Footnote 2
  For anglers who exceed daily catch quotas and possession limits, the proposed fine increase (of a $200 fine plus $50 per fish to a maximum of 10 fish) will align the fines of the Regulations with the provincial specified penalty established for the General Fisheries (Alberta) Regulation (AR 203/97) offence of keeping fish without holding an applicable special fish harvest licence and tag. Saskatchewan has a fine of $100 plus $25 per fish to a maximum of $1,000. British Columbia has a fine of $100 plus $50 per fish for a maximum of $1,000.
• Footnote 3
  British Columbia has a fine of $150, and Saskatchewan has a fine of $50 plus $25 per extra line up to a maximum of $1,000.
• Footnote 4
  SOR/98-246
• Footnote a
  S.C. 1991, c. 1, s. 12
• Footnote b
  S.C. 1991, c. 1, s. 24
• Footnote c
  R.S., c. F-14